Labels

Wednesday 19 September 2012

Plot devices that feminists don't like

Plot Devices that Make You Roll Your Eyes
  • a woman character is raped or is in danger of being raped -- the eternal rapability of female characters
  • a female character dies in childbirth
  • "convenient" circumstances prevent a female character from going through with her decision to have an abortion (cf. Robin in V, whose alien hybrid fetus's invasive vascularisation made it impossible to remove without killing her; spontaneous miscarriages and so forth) -- therefore rendering women's reproductive choices inconsequent when that oh-so-controversial subject is broached
  • using female characters to voice misogynistic and/or patriarchal ideas because it would be "too obvious" to use male characters — victim-blaming, in short
  • using evolutionary biology or the selfish gene theory as the primary reason a male and female character are drawn together sexually (Darwin's Radio by Bear), or why a female character cannot possibly resist the man's man that will make the best sire of her children (Lucifer's Hammer by Niven)
  • innocent and universally loveable female characters that do not develop a sex drive or sex appeal until they turn evil (Doppleganger Willow from earlier in Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Fred from Angel (TV series)) — where the sex drive is correlated with the amount of cleavage/leg shown.
  • alien women of ANY species will inevitably be irresistibly attracted to the only mid-30s male on a particular starship (Star Trek, I'm looking at YOU) — even if it causes an interstellar incident
    • related: females of alien species always have extremely large breasts, located in the exact same location as those of human females (i.e. they look exactly like human women except for a charming set of pointy ears, forehead ridges or swirly haircut that serves only to make them more exotic to the male characters)
  • a man's casual slap (or threatened slap) of a woman that is scarcely worth mentioning again in the story and apparently does not actually bother the woman; or maybe she likes it because he has now shown himself to be a real man. Seen in Frank Miller's "Sin City" (she liked it); Rob Reiner's "The Princess Bride" (He raises the back of his hand threateningly; she flinches. "That was a warning, Highness. The next time, my hand flies on its own, for where I come from, there are penalties when a woman lies."). This is entirely distinguishable from a man and a woman involved in a physical fight, as in Joss Whedon's "Firefly" between Mal and Saffron, or Buffy and Spike, or any slayer and various villains. "The Slap" is often stated plainly as a representation of patriarchy, as when the woman has crossed a boundary; the man may say he doesn't like to hit women but he'll make an exception, or she's crossed a line, etc. An obvious use of gendered violence to police patriarchal rules, present in both representations of the protagonists and villains.
  • The female member of the team whose skill or superpower is (by comparison) passive, defensive, weak, or underutilized; her real role is as token or love interest to the leading male characters. (See TvTropes' Faux Action Girl)
  • The trade-in granddaughter or descendant: A long-lived or immortal male starts a relationship with the hot young descendant of his former lover (or occasionally his own hot young descendant)
  • Simply grabbing the upper arm or shoulder of a superheroine or female fighter renders her helpless. (See TvTropes' Standard Female Grab Area)

No comments:

Post a Comment